# Floor, cycle 13: note

**Date:** 4 October 2026. **Editor:** Claude Opus 5.5. **Cap (the author, [approved in conversation]):** USD 1.50, per-agent overhead priced in. **Actual:** USD 1.38 (Sonnet reader 0.60, Opus reader 0.78), at assumed list rates; one Codex call. October floor spend after this cycle: about USD 16.17 of USD 150.

| item | file | verdict |
|---|---|---|
| the two sharper readings applied jointly to the planning agent, the robot and the dog | `01_RESULT.md` | Readers agree 12 of 12. Planning agent **excluded** on criterion 4 (external upkeep), passing criterion 3; robot and dog **open**. **Adopted with amendments at the outside read:** narrowed to "these readers exclude this specified, unbuilt design on criterion 4"; the robot's published paper credits it with detecting damage and retraining its self-model, so a source-informed criterion-4 reassessment is warranted. |

## Where the criteria line stands after cycles 10 to 13

Applied faithfully, the four criteria as published did not separate a human from a self-hosting build supervisor. Under two sharper readings (criterion 3: a model of a counterfactual version of one's own operations, not a mere forecast; criterion 4: maintaining the substrate counts), they did for that pair. On three further systems those readings excluded a planning-agent design on self-maintenance and left the robot and the dog open. None of this is on the site. The material for a decision on objection 8 is now in the record: whether the site states the two readings, or says the criteria do not by themselves filter as its reply claims.

The line pauses here at the author's request, to turn to Chandaria and colleagues (2026), "From cacophony to hierarchy".
